the agnostic investor

Written by Taraje Williams-Murray, CEO of Coroebus Wealth Management

financial planning and investment management simplified

The Illusion of Certainty

Humans crave certainty.

We want to know whether the market will rise next year. We want to know whether inflation has peaked, whether interest rates have topped out, and whether our retirement plan will succeed. Entire industries have been built around satisfying this desire.

The problem is that certainty is almost never available.

Yet investors continually demand it.

Interestingly, one of the world’s largest intelligence organizations learned this lesson decades ago. Rather than describing events as simply “likely” or “unlikely,” intelligence analysts adopted standardized probability language to communicate uncertainty more precisely.

Instead of speaking in absolutes, they distinguish between degrees of confidence:

ProbabilityInterpretation
100%Certain
About 93%Almost certain
About 75%Probable
About 50%Chances about even
About 30%Probably not
About 7%Almost certainly not
0%Impossible

Only two categories involve certainty: 100 percent and 0 percent.

Everything else—the overwhelming majority of real-world decisions—exists somewhere in between.

Investing is no different.

When television commentators announce that the Federal Reserve will cut rates, or that stocks must decline because of a particular economic report, they are often presenting opinions with a level of confidence the underlying evidence simply does not support.

Markets rarely operate in absolutes.

An investor who says, “The market will rally,” is making a statement of certainty.

A better investor asks:

“Given the available evidence, how probable is a rally?”

That small change in language fundamentally changes how decisions are made.

Instead of searching for the one correct answer, we prepare for several possible outcomes.

This shift is more than semantics. It changes portfolio construction, risk management, savings decisions, spending decisions and expectations.

Suppose you estimate there is roughly a 75 percent probability that equities outperform bonds over the next year. That doesn’t mean equities will outperform. It means you recognize a favorable probability while acknowledging meaningful uncertainty remains.

Likewise, a 30 percent chance of recession should not be ignored simply because it is less than fifty percent. Many of history’s most consequential market events began as relatively low-probability outcomes.

The objective is not to become certain.

Great investors understand that confidence should rise and fall with the quality of available evidence. They avoid speaking in absolutes because they recognize that today’s certainty often becomes tomorrow’s hindsight.

This concept is at the heart of how we think about financial planning at Coroebus Wealth Management and why we built Pythia®.

Instead, we believe technology should help investors understand the range of possible outcomes, assign reasonable probabilities, and make better decisions despite uncertainty.

The future is a distribution of possibilities. Improving your decision making is a continuous effort.

Sign up here to see how Pythia helps you make better financial decisions.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *